Customer reviews for Milani The Tank Liquid Eyeliner

Milani The Tank Liquid Eyeliner
$11.99
Prices may vary from online to in store

How to get it




  • Kokoa
    Reviewed 3 years ago

    Terrible! Will never buy again!

    This is horrible. The lies they tell on the package. It's sticky on my eyes. Smeared all over my eye lids. I do not recommend this at all. PLEASE BRING BACK INFINITE EYE LINER. IT WAS THE BEST!
    0 users found this review helpful.
    Originally posted on milani-cosmetics.com
  • ajax
    Reviewed 3 years ago

    Terrible after 3 uses

    I used it 3 times before it completely dried out :) love it. not worth it at all.
    0 users found this review helpful.
    Originally posted on milani-cosmetics.com
  • Andrea
    Verified purchase
    Reviewed 3 years ago

    Not for the waterline

    As soon as I applied it to my waterline is smeared a disappeared
    0 users found this review helpful.
    Originally posted on milani-cosmetics.com
  • Pony Girl
    Reviewed 3 years ago

    Never buy it again

    Not great at all. Unlike Infinite( which lasted almost 24 hrs for me and was discontinued) Tank looked horrible within 2 hrs. I sail, I ride horses and need a product that lasts...it is not Tank. Why Infinite was discontinued I do not know, most reviews showed that the product lasted. I need to spend the cash and go high end
    0 users found this review helpful.
    Originally posted on milani-cosmetics.com
  • annie
    Reviewed 3 years ago

    ugh

    Like others, i really miss the infinite eyeliner, and this is a poor replacement. The pigment is spotty, application streaky, and rubs off quickly. It says its waterproof but I haven't found that to be true. The formulation is terrible for folks with greasy eyelids, which the infinite was great for.
    0 users found this review helpful.
    Originally posted on milani-cosmetics.com
  • Lizzet
    Verified purchase
    Reviewed 3 years ago

    I would not recommend this product!!!

    This eyeliner doesnt compare the the infinite eyeliner at all it smears right off and doesnt stay at all comes right off!!! I was very dissatisfied with this product!!! Please bring back the infinite eyeliner that's the best pricy ever made!!!!
    0 users found this review helpful.
    Originally posted on milani-cosmetics.com
  • B
    Verified purchase
    Reviewed 3 years ago

    Bring back my go to eyeliner - Infinite please

    Ok but still does not stay on all day like Infinite. After trying over 50 brands Infinite was the only eyeliner I had found that did not smudge. Using it for many years. Tank is good but Infinite was best. Like the Tank applicator and that it can be shaken without a mess on the brush.
    0 users found this review helpful.
    Originally posted on milani-cosmetics.com
  • Rozel
    Verified purchase
    Reviewed 3 years ago

    No for me

    Was looking to find a replacement for the discontinued Infinite 24 hour liquid liner and this didn't even come close. I have oily lids and this smudged on my eyelids before I even left the house. Even tried an eyelid primer, powder, applying the liner, and more powder. Please bring back the Infinite 24 Hour liquid liner! Only thing that stays put.
    0 users found this review helpful.
    Originally posted on milani-cosmetics.com
Page 1 of 6

Details for Milani The Tank Liquid Eyeliner